Hey there, innovative minds, creative content creators, and global trailblazers!


If you’re an extraordinary talent aiming to sparkle in the U.S. under an O-1 visa, you know the drill: it’s all about proving you are at the top of your game. But what if checking off some of the traditional criteria feels like trying to fit a square peg in a round hole? Enter the world of comparable evidence, which can be the secret sauce to showcasing your unique brilliance and proving that you’re O-1 eligible.


The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) recognizes that not all heroes wear capes — or, in our case, not all extraordinary talents come with conventional accolades. That’s where the concept of comparable evidence – and the USCIS Policy Manual – comes into play, offering a guiding light through the fog.


According to the USCIS Policy Manual, when standard O-1 visa criteria might not fully capture an applicant’s extraordinary achievements or contributions, individuals can utilize “comparable evidence” instead. It’s like the USCIS saying, “We get it; your extraordinariness can’t always be boxed into traditional categories – show us what you’ve got, in your own way.”


Comparable evidence can be a beacon for innovators, creators, and pioneers especially in new fields or industries where the usual milestones just might not apply. Whether you’re transforming the digital landscape, revolutionizing social media, or leading in emerging tech, comparable evidence could allow you to paint a vivid picture of your exceptional prowess in your own way!


Understanding Comparable Evidence

First, it’s crucial to understand that the O-1 visa category is designed for individuals of extraordinary ability or achievement in their field. The law, and the USCIS Policy Manual, provides for the use of comparable evidence when the standard criteria may not adequately reflect an individual’s accomplishments or the nature of their field.


Strategic Use of Comparable Evidence

Comparable evidence can be a powerful tool in your O-1 application, if used correctly and strategically. It can allow you to tailor your evidence to better reflect your unique contributions and achievements. However, it’s not a matter of simply showing that standard criteria do not apply to your situation. Instead, it’s about demonstrating how your specific circumstances and accomplishments can be equivalently significant through alternative forms of evidence.


To Use Comparable Evidence, Do I Need to Show That All O-1 Criteria Do Not Apply?

No, you don’t. To use comparable evidence, the USCIS tells us that we are “not required to show that all or a majority of the criteria do not readily apply to the beneficiary’s occupation before USCIS will accept comparable evidence. Instead, for comparable evidence to be considered, the petitioner must explain why a particular evidentiary criterion listed in the regulations is not readily applicable to the beneficiary’s occupation, as well as why the submitted evidence is “comparable” to that criterion.”


Crafting Your O-1 Visa Application


Pick Which Criteria Applies Best to your Case

Review the evidentiary criteria for the O-1A or O-1B. Pick which of the 8 boxes (for O-1A) or 6 boxes (for O-1B) apply best to your case. An experienced O-1 immigration lawyer can advise you on this and can work with you to present the evidence in the strongest light.


Identify Which, if any, Criterion Does Not Apply to your Occupation or Industry

Review the standard O-1 visa criteria and see if any of them don’t apply to your field. This identification process is critical in determining where comparable evidence can be most effectively utilized. You will also need to explain – and document – why the specific criterion does not apply to you and thus, why you should be permitted to use comparable evidence instead.


Selecting Your Comparable Evidence

Choose evidence that closely mirrors the intent of the standard criterion, even if it doesn’t match the traditional format.



  • If the publication of scholarly articles is not readily applicable your field (because it’s an industry rather than academia) we can try to show that the presentation of your work at a major trade show is of comparable significance to that criterion.
  • If we show that receipt of a high salary is not readily applicable to your position as an entrepreneur, we can provide evidence that your highly valued equity holdings in the startup are of comparable significance to the high salary criterion.


Documentation and Explanation

For each piece of comparable evidence you plan to submit, provide thorough documentation and a clear explanation of its significance. Explain how this evidence reflects your extraordinary abilities or achievements and why it should be considered as a valid substitute for the standard criteria.


Legal Argument to (hopefully) Seal the Deal

Here’s where an experienced O-1 visa lawyer, like us, can really help. We can draft a specific legal argument that outlines why we should be permitted to use comparable evidence and then explicitly links your achievements with the spirit of the O-1 visa requirements. This argument can highlight how your contributions are extraordinary, even if they don’t fit traditional molds.



The Bottom Line

Comparable evidence is your chance to shine on your own terms. It’s about showing the immigration officers that your extraordinary talents deserve the spotlight, even if your path doesn’t follow traditional patterns.


Using comparable evidence in your O-1 visa application requires a thoughtful strategy and a clear understanding of what you need to prove. It’s not about showing a lack of fit for all criteria but rather demonstrating how one specific criterion does not fit, and how your unique achievements can be equivalently significant. With careful preparation and a strong legal argument, comparable evidence can significantly bolster your application.


If you have specific aspects of your achievements or contributions that you believe do not fit neatly into the standard criteria, let’s discuss them. Together, we can develop a strategy that effectively showcases your extraordinary abilities through comparable evidence and puts your best foot forward for an O-1 visa.


The O-1 visa can be your gateway to new horizons, and – for some – comparable evidence may be the key to unlocking it. Let’s make your American dream a reality, one extraordinary piece of evidence at a time!


 McEntee Law Group is a full service inbound US immigration law firm. Follow along for more educational articles and news updates! 


[gravityform id="3" title="true" description="false" ajax="true"]
[gravityform id="4" title="true" description="true" ajax="true"]